All blogs
The Role of AI in Hiring Vs Traditional Hiring Methods
Explore the dynamic landscape of hiring as AI transforms recruitment processes. Uncover the advantages, challenges, and real-world success stories.
Samuel
Growth@HireIntel
13th April 2024

Hiring can break or make a company as the right talent can help you grow, and the wrong talent could stop you in your tracks.

The talent acquisition industry is currently experiencing a shift as artificial intelligence systems are being introduced into the hiring process, revolutionizing the current traditional recruitment approaches followed by most companies.

Let’s deep dive into the current state of hiring and explore the differences between traditional and ai powered hiring, advantages, disadvantages, concerns and how the hiring process will evolve going forward into 2024.

The Current Hiring Landscape: Traditional vs. AI-powered Approaches

According to a study done by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), approximately 77% of HR professionals think that hiring procedures are becoming less dependent on human interaction.

Which is contradictory to what candidates are expecting.

More than 90% of candidates prefer human involvement especially in the final decision-making process.

Which makes sense, think about it if you were in the shoes of the candidate, how would you feel receiving an automated rejection or acceptance email without interacting with anyone from said company?

AI HR Tech Market Growth: Trends and Forecasts

The artificial intelligence hiring tech industry is experiencing rapid growth, expected to reach a value of $1 trillion in the United States alone by 2028.

McKinsey states that 50% of tasks can be automated currently, but only around one-third of HR tasks are typically automated. Meaning, there is a lot of room for automated solutions to fill the gaps.

Current AI Usage in Hiring Recruitment

At the present time, 65% of recruiters are using AI in the hiring process.

Among the generations, Millennials show a greater level of distrust towards the use of AI in their hiring process, with over 70% being suspicious, as opposed to approximately 59% in older age demographics.

Which is a surprising metric as we often think that the youngest generation would be more welcoming of technology.

Advantages of Artificial Intelligence in Hiring

Bias Reduction through Automation

Traditional recruitment places a strong reliance on manual procedures and human discretion when assessing candidates.

This method, although offering a personalized experience, might require a lot of time.

On the other hand, AI recruitment uses artificial intelligence to automate tasks and reduce bias, ensuring a more impartial assessment of job seekers.

Example: An artificial intelligence system quickly reviewing resumes against other applicants in the same pool to eliminate any chance of bias during the initial screening phase.

Quick Screening and Data-driven Insights

AI integration allows for quick evaluation of CVs and offers data-driven analysis to enhance decision-making.

This approach utilizes data to improve the accuracy of candidate selection specifically for the job role that you are looking to fill, leading to better hiring results.

Example: An artificial intelligence (AI) program examining large sets of data to pinpoint the most appropriate candidates for the role, which could have taken days to do following traditional hiring procedures.

Striking the Balance between Personalization and Efficiency

Although traditional approaches prioritize personalization and a focus on individuals, AI recruitment stands out for its effectiveness and quickness and unbiased judgment of the applicants.

Achieving the perfect equilibrium requires combining the individualized touch of conventional approaches with the effectiveness of AI in a hybrid manner.
Example: Imagine a hiring process that merges the personalized feel of traditional methods such as interviews with the effectiveness of AI used to automate shortlisting the best candidates from a pool of applicants, ensuring a comprehensive approach to selecting candidates.

Adapting to the Modern Hiring Landscape

Both traditional recruitment methods and AI recruitment are focused on attracting the top talent.

However, AI recruitment shows greater skill in adjusting to the fast-evolving hiring requirements, giving companies a competitive edge.
Example: Ideally an organization embracing AI tools to streamline hiring, carry out talent searches, and stay competitive in the ever-evolving recruitment landscape.

Finding the correct balance between human judgment and technological innovation is essential as the recruitment environment experiences a significant change.

Businesses who utilize AI in their hiring processes gain a competitive advantage by optimizing their hiring procedures and quickly adjusting to the changing demands of modern hiring practices.

This leads to improved hiring outcomes in the constantly changing hiring environment of today.

Challenges and Considerations in AI-powered Hiring

AI has transformed the field of Human Resources by offering more efficient processes and improved decision-making capabilities.

However, with great power comes great responsibility.

Let's explore the opportunities and challenges associated with the implementation of AI in HR Tech.

Understanding AI's Capabilities:

Hiring managers, keen to utilize the power of AI, frequently encounter a challenge.

Which is,
Understanding the complete range of AI's abilities, this results in either overly high expectations of what the AI tool can do or not making the most of it because they fail to understand its full potential.

It's like having a powerful tool but not knowing all the functions it offers.

To bridge this gap, education and training on AI's capabilities are crucial.

As companies adapt new technologies, and techniques to refine their hiring process, they need to help their hiring team understand how to fully utilize and leverage the new processes and avoid potential traps.

Privacy Concerns in Data Handling

Data privacy has been a sensitive subject over the past decade as we’ve seen many companies misuse user data and data breaches.

With AI becoming more prevalent in recruitment, data privacy is starting to become a concern for both companies and individuals alike.

Because so much personal data is at risk, businesses find it difficult to safeguard sensitive data.

To navigate this problem, robust data protection policies are essential.

Companies must establish clear guidelines for the ethical use of data, ensuring compliance with regulations and fostering trust with candidates.

This bridge not only safeguards personal information but also strengthens the foundation for a successful AI-HR partnership.

Addressing Bias in AI Algorithms

Not all AI Algorithms are created equal. As we have seen in the past with many AI Algorithms even from tech giants such as Google and Microsoft often produce “hallucinated” data.

This problem stems from the data that the AI systems are trained with.

If AI systems are taught with biased data, they will continue forming biased judgements, leading to unjust hiring practices.
It acts as an obstacle in the journey towards establishing diverse and welcoming work environments.

To tackle this problem,

Companies need to regularly audit and update their AI algorithms.
This serves as a checkpoint for organizations to detect and correct any biases that they have observed.

By making fairness a priority, companies create opportunities for a diverse and skilled workforce.

Embracing AI in HR should not be a leap of faith but a carefully guided journey.

Gaining knowledge about AI's abilities through learning, enforcing strong data protection measures, and conducting frequent algorithm audits are key factors in achieving success.
In HR's future, it is not only about technology but also about making deliberate decisions to move us toward a fairer and more effective work environment.

Case Studies: Success Stories and Lessons Learned

The use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has led to major changes in the rapidly changing realm of hiring and human resources.

Let's examine actual examples of how leading companies have used AI to solve problems and achieve impressive results.

 Tier 4 Group: Overcoming Coding Exam Hurdles

In the first success story, Tier 4 Group faced hurdles in their hiring process due to stringent coding exams excluding capable developers.

Solution: They introduced a custom-built interview platform for more effective candidate screening.

Outcome: The tailored evaluation led to successful recruitment without the need for personal interviews.

Unilever: Streamlining Global Recruitment

Unilever aimed to streamline its global recruitment process while ensuring fair assessment of candidates.

Unilever aimed to streamline its global recruitment process while ensuring fair assessment of candidates.

Solution: Unilever introduced an AI-driven platform for screening entry-level hires using online assessments and video interviews.

Outcome: A significantly shortened hiring process, also resulting in a more diverse candidate selection while overcoming human biases.

Babynama Case Study with Hireintel: Automating Entry-Level Hiring

Facing the challenge of hiring entry-level roles for customer support with limited time and manpower, Babynama partnered with Hireintel.

Solution: Streamlining and automating initial screening rounds, conducting AI interviews to rank candidates based on job fit metrics.

Outcome: Babynama successfully found the best-fit candidates, saving significant time and effort in the process.

AI-HR Tech Trends That will Transform the Hiring Landscape in 2024

It will be critical for both businesses and job seekers to keep up with the most recent developments in the rapidly changing employment landscape as we progress into 2024.

In a recent Forbes article, Luciana Paulise outlines three hiring trends for 2024, with a primary focus on AI-driven innovations.

Employers and job seekers alike are increasingly turning to hiring platforms such as LinkedIn, Indeed etc… and the quality of their experiences on these platforms plays a crucial role.

Artificial Intelligence is playing a pivotal role in enhancing these experiences, from streamlining the recruitment process to improving candidate engagement with the company.

The use of AI in hiring goes beyond mere efficiency gains.

AI in hiring aims to create a seamless and personalized experience for job seekers, ensuring that their journey from application to onboarding is as smooth as possible.

Personalization in candidate experience:

As per findings from HelloHire, the future of hiring is centered on personalized recruitment paths.

This trend highlights the significance of customizing interactions with candidates, beginning with the first contact and lasting through the onboarding process.

AI plays a central role in this task, offering the resources needed to craft a distinct experience for every individual applying.

The significance of customized encounters is important.

They not only result in increased candidate satisfaction and engagement, but also foster deeper connections between organizations and potential employees.

In a time when talent is highly valuable, focusing on the candidate experience can be crucial for attracting and keeping top talent.

AI-Powered Onboarding:

As we explore further into the future of recruitment, the impact of AI expands into the area of welcoming new employees. AI is drastically changing the onboarding process with automated procedures, personalized training plans, mentorship suggestions, and immediate feedback.

The outcome is clear: better onboarding procedures facilitate new hire transitions and increase employee satisfaction and retention. Businesses may ensure that their new hires are ready for success from the beginning by using AI during onboarding.

Integration with Existing HR Tech:

The progress of AI in recruitment includes its incorporation with current HR tools like Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) and Learning Management Systems (LMS).

This integration is forming cohesive HR systems driven by data to improve effectiveness in different HR areas such as hiring, talent management, and employee growth.

The benefits of this integration are significant.

Businesses have the ability to utilize artificial intelligence to make decisions based on data, optimize processes, and enhance their broader human resources strategy. Moving ahead, the partnership between artificial intelligence and human resources technology will further influence the future of the labor force.

Conclusion: Navigating the Future of HR with AI

In conclusion, adopting a hybrid hiring approach appears to be the optimal method, considering candidates' preference for human interaction and the impracticality of immediately overhauling companies' established hiring processes.

Looking ahead to 2024, it becomes increasingly crucial for individuals to proactively educate themselves.

This proactive stance is essential as numerous companies and platforms integrate AI into their recruitment pipelines. By enhancing their understanding of AI's role in hiring, candidates can significantly improve their chances of effectively showcasing their value in the evolving job market.

ai hiring ai vs traditional hiring methods
Share this post
share to twitter share to facebook share to linkedin
Categories
Trends Misc Hiring Process Candidate Sourcing HR Hiring Tools